Go beyond compassion: celebrating other’s flourishing

Compassion is a beautiful thingWhat is compassion? It is a four parted phenomenon of witnessing, acknowledging, and feeling of others’ pain and responding with compassionate actions that alleviate the pain. This is a topic close to my heart and I have written about it.

Compassion is hard. It requires moral imagination to feel other’s pain, especially those of strangers. Compassion is also easy. Because when you feel the pain, you act in a way to reduce someone else’s pain thereby reducing your own agony and discomfort. In turn it makes you also feel better about yourself. Compassion being a response to pain has a strong affective component and therefore may be transient and not enduring. For example, you may feel moved to contribute to the latest earthquake relief after watching the TV coverage, but you may move on to other parts of your life without getting embroiled in it.

Compared to compassion, it seems to be much harder to witness celebrate other’s flourishing. Why is it so hard to celebrate others’ victories, achievements, and joy? Your friend may have written a book that topped the New York Times Best seller list. How do you react to it? Is it easy for you to react with positivity and appreciation? You cousin may have gotten married to the hottie who is also brilliant and kind. How do you react to it? Especially if your husband is an alcoholic slob? What about your neighbor that hit it rich and moved to the beautiful house with the million dollar view? How do you react to it? In these cases, there is no pain to respond. Witnessing and sharing in other people’s joy requires you to move your mental model to one of transcendence in which you feel you and the other are not separate. It requires to capacity for joy and not just pain. What do you need to move your mental model?

1. Are you objectively self-aware? What does that even mean? This is a human dilemma in which you are both the subject and the object. This demands deep and critical reflection. It is a tightrope dance because while you want to be self aware, you don’t want to be self conscious, especially of the public variety. Public self consciousness is not beneficial because one is then obsessed with how others perceive and/or judge them. Private self consciousness on the other hand is paying attention to your own feelings, thoughts, and emotions. But taken too far, it too becomes an obsession. Meditative and mindfulness practices such as Transcendental Meditation, Vipassana Meditation are examples of practice that can help you develop the capacity for objective self-awareness. So are other practices such as yoga in its traditional form, art and other aesthetic pursuits which put you in flow, when coupled with reflective practice.

2. Do you possess emotionality, i.e. the tendency to experience a variety of emotions? Positive Psychology brought our attention to positive emotions and human flourishing. Which is a very good thing. To move from a pathology centered approach to flourishing approach is a positive evolutionary step! But I have always been concerned that the positive psychology movement may inadvertently silence negative emotions, thus invalidating emotions that exist and may even be warranted. For example, this school of thought terms, gratitude, forgiveness, compassion and empathy, and humility as the sacred emotions. What about moral outrage? May it not be considered sacred emotion?  Most recent research alleviates this concern. A multi-school study offers evidence that emotional variety and diversity is essential for mental and physical well being. This makes more sense in the mindfulness framework too. Mindfulness is not about suppressing a certain set of emotions but it is about accepting and experiencing all of them. So if you can feel anger, joy, guilt, sadness, happiness, compassion and the whole gamut, more power to you! You will not only have less hospital visits, but you can also shift your mental models about how to relate to the world.

3. Just because you are able to experience different sets of emotions doesn’t mean you need to run and act on all of them at the moment you experience them. The third important question: do you have a set of highly developed emotional regulatory processes? Individual capacity to regulate one’s emotions is linked to morally relevant and social behavior. How do you regulate yourself better? Interestingly you need to go back to Items 1 and 2. Developing the capacity to experience and articulate  a range of discrete emotions is essential for emotional self regulation. Which in turn can benefit from developing the capacity for objective self awareness.

To go back to our original question, if you feel pain at other people’s happiness, success or joy, embrace it in the moment. Ask yourself why you feel the pain and engage in self-compassion . Then you can regulate your negative reaction, feel a deep connection to the other person and express positive support and approbation and share in the joy. That way, you don’t have to fake it till make it. You can actually feel it. Faking it is rigorous emotional labor and very stressful. Much better to focus on shifting your mental model to truly connect and rejoice in others’ successes.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Personal Growth, The next Frontier and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Go beyond compassion: celebrating other’s flourishing

  1. Reblogged this on Next Step to Nirvana and commented:

    Go beyond Compassion!

    Like

  2. Very interesting post. Your point about the limitations of Positive Psychology particularly stood out to me. I’m a total newbie to this stuff but I recently started watching a couple of YouTube videos about it… It seemed like a great concept overall, but one user asked in the comments: “So what if one of your loved ones dies in front of you? Should you still feel no negative emotion?” The creator of the video answered: “Technically, no, you shouldn’t.” That put me off somewhat… Of course I want to be a positive person, but without some negative emotion where it’s warranted, would we truly be human? Hence I completely agree with your point. 😊

    But then again, as I said, I am totally new to this so I may have a long way to go before I fully understand the positive psychology perspective!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yusra

      Thank you for your thoughtful comment. And welcome to my blog.

      I cannot say that I am totally new to Positive Psychology and there is a lot of truth/applicability to it. But at the same time I am concerned that mindfulness does not mean you ignore all the negative feelings. But it is more about acknowledging and accepting the negative feelings but moving past them and/or using them positively.

      Looking forward to a continuing conversation

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thank you for the warm welcome! I am always looking for ways to improve myself and your blog has lots of useful articles about self-improvement, so I like it a lot! 😊

    Thank you also for the clarification. Yes, it definitely feels seems better (and more human) to use negative energy in positive ways rather than to not feel anything at all 🙂

    Like

    • I just saw that you are a poet. No wonder you want to feel the spectrum of emotions. As a human being too, but as a person of color from a post colonial setting, I cannot imagine how we can do away with negative emotions! I strongly believe that moral anger has a place in social change. Yes, it doesn’t mean one has to go blowing up others because they found it offensive, but in the spirit of Gandhi and Dr. King, it is important not to be co-opted under the guise of all positivity. Did you read my article on managing anxiety? It carries the same tone.

      Like

      • Awww, thank you for stopping by my blog! I think what you mentioned earlier about turning negative energy into positive was the main thing which prompted me to start a poetry blog in the first place. Creative writing for me is such an effective form of catharsis. It may sound ridiculous, but even if I am feeling as sad as hell about something, I usually feel at least a little better if I can write an accurate and evocative simile to describe my situation. ^_^ Turning pain into something pretty is such a stress-killer… And you can kill two birds with one stone (not that I approve of killing birds in the literal sense, of course… Hahaha :-P) – because you’re not only reducing your own negativity, but you’re also putting out an art form into the world which others can enjoy.

        You are right. In an ideal utopian world, where everyone is perfect and positive and living in absolute justice and harmony, I suppose there would be no need for moral anger, but we have a long way to go before our world becomes that squeaky-clean. And as such, social change must be continuously promoted. We need to be passionately indignant in order to do that. 😊

        As for where I found your blog, you liked one of my comments on another blog called “AlmostFreeinNYC.” I got the notification and you seemed like a nice enough person so I decided to come and check out your blog and see what you are up to ^_^ Heheheh. I hope you don’t mind. I am very glad I did come along because I am learning some interesting things here.

        Liked by 1 person

        • Fantastic! Exactly. Moral indignation has a place. Cool that you followed me from another blog 🙂 I love the Halal Guys and so had to comment. I am also writing as a regenerative strategy. I too am very glad you came along! This is the type of conversation I had hoped to have to nourish my spirit. So, thank you.

          Like

          • You are most welcome! 😊 Hope the regenerative strategy is working for you so far… And it’s doubly good because the topics you write about will help to regenerate others in the same situation, too! 😊 Lots of good karma for you. Keep going! 😊😊 Also, I have never been to NYC (or even America, in fact… I’m based in the UK) and I have never tried the Halal Guys, either but that did not stop my mouth from watering while looking at the post… Hahaha so I had to like it, too! 😊😊

            Liked by 1 person

    • If I might ask, how did you find this blog?

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s